1. Harry Milton (b.Mar 1882 MI)
2. Earnest Claud (b.May 1886 MI)
3. Earl S. (b.May 1894 WA)
4. Lester Harold (b.July 1896 WA)
5. Paul Vernon (b.May 1902 OR)

1. Octavia (b.1844)
2. Mary Selvina (b.1847)
3. Lavina (b.1849)
4. Charlotte (b.1851)
5. Philip (b.1856)

Research of Kevin Everingham 2004-2011;
1860 CENSUS Scio, Allegany, New York (family #189) ... Wm. Evingham 40 b.NY,... Jane 40, b.NY,.. Octavia 17, b.NY,.. Mary V. 13, b.NY,.. Lavina 11, b.NY,.. Charlotte 9, b.NY,.. Philip 4, b.NY,.. Wm. 2, b.NY

1870 CENSUS Cuba, Allegany, New York, July 1870 (family #529) ... Jane Evingham 49, keeps boarders, b.NY,.. Charlotte Evingham 18, at home,.. Philip Evingham 14,.. William Evingham 13,.. Frank Thomas 31, works in saw mill,.. Harlan Thomas 27, works in saw mill,.. Albert Russell 21, works in saw mill,.. Edward Olmsted 25, works in saw mill,.. Abner Bissell 27, works in saw mill,.. Julius Patterson 20, works in saw mill.

1872 Alcona MI Birth Record .. .Holmes Benny Witter Griswold, b.26 Nov 1872 at Harrisville, Alcona, MI, s/o Harry C. Griswold, b.PA,.. Helen M. Griswold b.NY. AKA "Benjamin" in 1880 Census below

1875 Alcona Birth Record (pg.4 #206)... Guy C. Griswold, b.28 Dec 1875 at Harrisville, Alcona, MI, s/o H.C. Griswold b.PA, and Hellen M. Griswold, b.NY.

this may or may not be the same person:
1880 Greenbush, Alcona County, Michigan ... William Effingham 22, laborer, born in NY, parents born in NY,... was living with Jeremiah Perkins & others.

1880 CENSUS Harrisville, Alcona, MI (Page 21C)... Harvey C. Griswold 60, b.PA,.. Helen Griswold 47, wife, b.NY,.. May Jackson 18, b.NY, dau,.. Carrie Griswold 16, b.NY, dau,.. William Griswold 12, b.NY, son,.. Benjamin Griswold 7, b.NY, son,.. Guy C. Griswold 4, b.MI.

1880 MI Marriage Record ... William Henry Evingham 22, (b.~1858), born in New York... & ... Carrie Adeline Griswold 18, b.New York (b.~1862)... married 2 Nov 1880 at Harrisville, Alcona, MI. this same year she was only 16 in the CENSUS record... maybe claimed to be older to get married?

Additional research 2013 by Kevin Everingham of MI
Pilot Butte Cemetery Bend, Deschutes County, Oregon, lists the following; Carrie Evringham 1864-1919,.. William Evringham 1856-1928,.. Ernest Evringham 1886-1919,.. Harry Evringham 1882-1919.

They moved to Washington by the 1890's (based on Census & Birth info)

1900 CENSUS Kamakawa, Wahkiakum County, Washington (Sheet 5A #101)... Wm. H. Everingham 42, b.Mar 1858 PA, married 19 years,.. Carrie A. 36, b.Dec 1863 NY, wife, mother of 6 children, 4 living,.. Harry M. 18, b.Mar 1884 MI,.. Earnest 14, b.May 1886 MI,.. Earl S. 8, b.May 1894 WA,.. Lester H. 3, b.July 1896 WA. This seems like a perfect match except William being born in PA.. although they had just come from living in Michigan near Carrie's family and her father was born in Pennsylvania, maybe she filled out the Census and this is where the mixup came in?

1919 .. Carrie died (see Deschutes Cemetery listing above) + Certificate #9, Oregon Death Index... Carrie Evringham d.27 Jan 1919 at Deschutes, OR.
1920 CENSUS Deschutes, Oregon (Sheet 8, home #4) ... William H. Evringham 61, b.NY, widowed, parents b.NY. Wiliam died in 1928. (cemetery listing above)
1928 Certificate #101, Oregon Death Index.. William Evringham, d.10 Oct 1928 at Deschutes, OR