1. William (b.July 1866 NY)
2. John H. (b.~1868 NY)
3. Edward (b.~1869 NY died young)

1. Nancy M. (b.~1842)
2. Cyrus (b.~1848)

Research of Kevin Everingham 2004-2011;
1850 CENSUS Amity, Allegany, New York ... (family #84) Sidney Evingham 33,.. Elizabeth 33,.. Nancy M. 8,.. Jonathan 5,.. Cyrus 2.

1865 STATE CENSUS Amity, Allegany, NY (Page 23, dwelling #168) .. Sidney Evingham 47,.. Elizabeth 47,.. Mary F. 14,.. Susan K. 13. next home, next page; dwelling #169 Jonathan Evingham 19,.. Clara Evingham 18, wife.

1870 CENSUS Amity, Allegany, New York ... Jonathan Evringham 24, farmer, Clara J. 22 keeping house, William 4, John 2, Edward 1 ... all born in New york.

1875 STATE CENSUS amity, Allegany, NY (#266) ... Johnithan Evingham 29, b.NY, farmer,.. Mary J. 27, wife, b.WIS, William 8, b.Allegany,.. Johney 7, b.Allegany.

1880 CENSUS Amity, Allegany, New York (Page 69A, #1521)... Johnithan Ervingham 34 b.NY, laborer,.. Clara J. Ervingham 33, b.WI,.. William 13, son, b.NY,.. John 12, son, b.NY.

1892 STATE CENSUS Amity, Allegany, New York... Sidney Evingham 74, farmer,.. Johnathan 45, Clara J. 44, William 25, (John 22, Rhoda 20) John & Rhoda were a married couple.

1900 CENSUS Belmont Vil, Allegany, New York ... Jonathan Evingham, b.May 1845 NY,... Clara J. b.May 1848 NY, wife, mother of 2, 2 living,... Wiliam b.July 1866 NY, son, married 8 yrs (abt 1892),... Harry, b.Jan 1893 NY, grandson,... Edith, b.Sept 1873 NY, daughter-in-law, married 8 yrs, mother of 1... Lottie, b.April 1894 NY, granddaughter.

1905 STATE CENSUS Amity, Allegany, New York... Jonathan Evingham 59, Clara J. wife, 57,.. Harry, nephew 12.

1910 CENSUS Amity, Allegany, NY ... Jonathan Evingham 63, Clara J. 61, wife,... Harry 17, nephew, b.PA,... George 46, b.NY, brother-in-law ???

1919 The Bolivar Breeze, Thursday, Jan 16, 1919... "Old Allegany section... Johnathan Evingham died at his home in the town of Amity on January 8, he was aged 73 years."
1919 The Belmont Dispatch, Belmont, NY, Fri, Feb 14, 1919.. "Proof of Will of Jonathan Evingham, late of Amity, letters issued to Clara J. Evingham."

1920 CENSUS Amity, Allegany, NY ... John H. Evingham 51 b.NY, widowed, father b.NY, mother b.WI,.. Clara Evingham 71, b.WI, widowed, mother.

1928 The Belmont Dispatch, Friday, April 6, 1928 ... "Mrs. Clara Evingham Mrs. Clara Evingham, aged 79, died at her home on the Plumbottom road Tuesday. The funeral services are being held today at two o'clock at the home. Burial in Forest Hills cemetery. Deceased is survived by two sons, William and John Evingham, a nephew Harry Evingham; two sisters, Mrs. Mary Brown and Mrs. Ida Brown; three brothers, Verne Evingham of Oswago, Pa., George Evigham of Wellsville and John Evingham of Scio; two granddaughters and one great-grandson. "