married:
Lavenia GORTEN
m.6 June 1906 Manhattan, NY
d/o James Gorten & Lavenia Bunting

EVERNHAM
1. Joseph Henry (b.1 April 1880 NY)
2. Benjamin John (b.11 Aug 1882 NY)
3. Clarence (b.15 Dec 1884 NY)
4. Jessie (b.June 1886 NY)

1. James (b.11 Jul 1850)
2. Caroline (b.~1851)
3. Mary Emma (May 4, 1854)
4. Emeline "Evaline" (Sept.28, 1856)
5. Warren M. (1859 d.1863)
6. Benjamin A. (b.1861) Ocean, NJ
7. Lucinda (Feb 23, 1864)
8. John H. (b.3 Dec 1867)
9. Jessie Pearce (b.1869) Ocean, NJ
10. Ann "Annie" (b.20 Oct 1871)

Research of Kevin Everingham of MI, 2018

1860 US CENSUS Dover twp, Ocean, NJ (house #152).. "Benj. Evernham 35, b.NJ,.. Naoma J. 27, b.NJ,.. Caroline 8, b.NJ,.. Thos. C. 6, b.NJ,.. Mary E. 6, b.NJ,.. Eva 3, b.NJ,.. Morell 1, b.NJ."

1876 Ocean County Marriage Record (E, Page 143).. "Thos. C. Evernham, single, male, s/o B.D. & Naomi Evernham ... and Sena Wanser 18, single, female, d/o Henry & Margt Wanser... married 17 March 1876 at Berkeley, Ocean, NJ."

1880 US CENSUS Long Island, Queens, New York, June 8, 1880, (Sheet 15A, house #11271504, line 298)... "Thomas Everham 26, b.NJ, fireman,.. Sena 20, wife, b.NY,.. Joseph, infant 1/12, son, b.NY" SSDI shows Joseph Evernham, b.1 April 1880 NY, died Feb 1963.

1882 (New York births and christenings 1640-1962).. "Benjamin Evernham, male, b.11 Aug 1882 at Long Island, Queens, NY, son of; Thomas Evernham & Sena Wansor"... His 1918 WWI draft registration gives a middle name of "John" and shows birth date of Sept 11, 1882.

1884 New York births & christenings 1640-1962... "Clarence Evernham, male, b.15 Dec 1884 at Long Island, Queens, NY. son of Thomas Everham."

same Thomas C.? slightly older, but has a son named Joseph also a year younger than the 1880 CENSUS. The transcribed records below are likely the same family, see; 1906 marriage record below.
1900 US CENSUS Brooklyn, Kings, New York,... "Thomas C. Evernham, 48, b.May 1852 NJ, parents b.NJ, married 1 yr,.. Joseph 19, b.April 1881 NY,.. Benjamin 17, b.Jan 1883 NY,.. Clarence, 15, b.1885 NY,.. Jessie 13, b.June 1886 NY, (all sons)."

1906 New York marriage records.. "Thomas Cook Everham, 50, widowed, s/o Benjamin Everham & Eliza Phillips, married June 6, 1906 at Manhattan, NY, NY to Lavenia Gorten, 40, single, d/o James Gorten & Lavenia Bunting."

1910 US CENSUS Brooklyn, Kings, NY (Sheet 14B, house #304)... "Thomas C. Evernham 57, b.NJ, married 5 yrs, engineer at Machine Shop,.. Lavenia G. 48, wife, b.NY, married 5 yrs, mother of 0 children,.. Joseph H. 29, son, b.NY, Engineer,.. Jesse 24, son, b.NY, bookbinder at a Bindery,.. Harold 2, b.NY, grandson"

1925 STATE CENSUS Brooklyn, Kings, NY (Page 44, house #80).. "Thomas Evernham 72,.. Lavenia Evernham 62, wife,.. Joseph Evernham 41, son."

1930 US CENSUS Queens, Queens, NY (Sheet 22A, house #410).. "Stanley MacKenna 29, b.NY,.. Alice MacKenna 63, b.NY, mother,.. Thomas C. Evernham 76, b.NJ, uncle,.. Lavenia Evernham 67, b.NY, aunt."

1935 NY Municipal deaths.. "Benjamin Evernham 53, died 25 Nov 1935 at New York City, Richmond, NY, son of; Thomas Evernham & ___ Wanzer,.. spouse Lizzie."