1. Grace Eunecia (b.3 Aug 1873)
2. Benjamin F. (b.1876)
3. William (b.14 Apr 1878)

1882 Marriage registration,... John W. Wingate & Eliza S. Painter, married 10 Jun 1882 at Hardin OH.

1884 Birth registration, ... Ada Pearl Wingate, b.5 Nov 1884 at Liberty, Hardin, OH... d/o J.W. Wingate & Eliza Painter.

1900 CENSUS Toledo, Lucas Co. OH... J.W. Wingate, married 18yrs, b.Jan 1862 OH... Eliza, b.Mar 1865 OH, wife... Ralph, b.Mar 1883... Ada, b.Dec 1884 OH,... Effie, b.Aug 1889 OH.

1902 marriage registration... Herbert Everingham 23, b.OH, s/o Wm. B Everingham & Catherine Horn,... Ada Wingate 19, d/o Wesley Wingate & Eliza Painter.... m.28 July 1902 at Lucas, Ohio.

1920 Death registration... Wesley R. Wingate (b.2 Mar 1885 Ada, OH), d.12 Dec 1920 at Toledo, Lucas OH, single, 35y - 9mo - 10d,.. s/o J. Wesley Wingate & Eliza Painter. brother of Ada?

(kevin) - I don't find Herbert & Ada in any Census data together.