1. Clarissa (b.~1848 CAN)
2. Charity (b.~1852 NY)
3. Samuel Sutliff (b.1854 NY)
4. Catherine Elmira (b.1856 NY)
5. Cecilia Edna (b.1857 NY)
6. Caroline Emily (b.1861 NY)

1. Jacob
2. Bassnett
3. Sullivan
4. Adoram
5. Anna
6. Margaret
7. Martin
8. Daniel
9. James

Research of Kevin Everingham of Michigan, 2012

1870 CENSUS New York, New York ... Sutliff Staley 51, b.NY,.. Catharine 51, b.CAN,.. Clarissa 22, b.CAN,.. Charity 18, b.NY,.. Samuel 16, b.NY,.. Elmira 14, b.NY,.. Edna 12, b.NY,.. Carrie 8, b.NY.

1880 CENSUS Grand Island, Erie, New York (Page 369A)... Sutlif Staly 60, b.NY,.. Catharine 60, b.CAN,.. Clarissa 32, b.CAN,.. Carrie E. 18, b.NY,.. Frank Ockerman 19, b.NY,.. Catharine Ort 18, b.CAN,.. Elmira Staly 24, b.NY,.. Peter McCray 30, b.CAN.

1886 NY Marriage Record... Caroline Emily Staley 24, d/o Suflief Staley,... & Arthur Edmund Bennett, s/o Stephen Bennett,... married July 28, 1886 at Grace Episcopal Church, Buffalo, Erie, New York.